Sign up for our Newsletter

Sylvester Manor Educational Farm’s history and ghost stories will converge this Halloween for its Mysteries of the Manor tour.

On Saturday, October 31, the manor will host ghost tours and take visitors on a haunted hayride of the farm.  Sylvester Manor has more than just rumors of ghosts; there is actual documentation of ghostly occurences dating back hundreds of years.

“It allows us to weave entertainment into history and the cultural landscape here,” explained Maura Doyle, Sylvester Manor’s historic preservation coordinator.

“Every one of our ghost stories actually happened and we know that person actually existed and has some place in the narrative here. We do not judge; I myself have never had a paranormal experience, but many other people have,” Doyle said. “What’s fascinating is that there are references to some of these experiences in the family archive that is now at New York University. That’s 10,000 documents that include wills, ledgers and correspondence.”

This nearly 400-year-old manor has more than its fair share of history and ghost stories. Some of the stories relate to specific items that still exist in the house, like a haunted mirror, while others detail parts of the property that visitors can see for themselves.

A female servant has been sighted many times haunting this glade of trees visible from the house. (Credit: Monique Singh-Roy)
A female servant has been sighted many times haunting this glade of trees visible from the house. (Credit: Monique Singh-Roy)

For example there have been reports of a female spirit allegedly haunting a section of woods near the manor house.

“She flits in and out of the trees,” Doyle said. “The story goes that she was an indentured servant from Ireland. She is seen around there because her toddler drowned in a nearby pond where they used to water the livestock.”

Another ghost story pertains to a specific mirror in the house in which more than one person has reported seeing a woman in white in the reflection.

“It is a 1750s London-made mahogany and gilt looking glass,” Doyle explained. “This is the one that for more than 100 years has been referred to as having the spirit of a woman appear in it.”

A mysterious woman in white has reportedly been seen by more then one person looking into this mirror that dates back to the 1750s. (Credit: Monique Singh-Roy)
Several people have reported seeing a mysterious woman in white looking back at them from this mirror that dates back to the 1750s. (Credit: Monique Singh-Roy)

There are many more ghostly tales attributed to the manor. One story claims that alleged pirate Captain Kidd reportedly murdered two pirates who now haunt the property.

“Captain Kidd was genuinely involved with Sylvester Manor,” Doyle said. “He would take goods from the manor and take them to market and he would take a consignment fee for doing this — it’s in the archive. He genuinely buried treasure on Gardiner’s Island, that is in the historic record.

“We want this event to be authentic,” Doyle continued. “These are all stories or people that connect with this place in its timeline, so it’s not just a generic mummy or zombie; these were real people.”

On Halloween, Saturday, October 31, Sylvester Manor Educational Farm will host Mysteries of the Manor from 1 to 4 p.m. Volunteers will tell ghost stories during house tours. There will also be a haunted hayride that will make stops at various haunted locations on the property, while a guide tells spooky tales. There will also be a costume parade, a treasure hunt, snacks and warm cider. Tickets are $5 per person, children aged 4 and under are free. House tours require a reservation in advance. This event is free for Sylvester Manor members. For more information call (631) 749-0626 or visit To purchase tickets go to Eventbrite.