The nuts and bolts
4 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
1,985 square feet
.10 acres
House proud
A renovation in 2022 gave this charming corner-lot Victorian a facelift inside and out with new windows, newly reinforced beams and joists, a raised roofline for additional headroom and updated electric. The bathrooms and kitchen were all updated as well, as was the first-floor plan, adding a laundry room and other renovations.
“The current owners, experienced in restoring vintage homes in the Hamptons, applied their expertise and keen eye to this iconic Shelter Island Heights Victorian,” says Penelope Moore, who is representing the listing at Saunders. “They reconfigured the layout to improve functionality for modern living while preserving the home’s integrity and timeless charm.”
What’s the plan?
“The house is thoughtfully designed for entertaining,” Moore says. The first level features a living room of nearly 600 square feet, anchored by a wood-burning fireplace, a bay window and a wall of multi-paned windows overlooking the backyard. There is also a 125-square-foot flexible guest room with access to a full bathroom.
Upstairs, the primary bedroom features an ensuite bathroom, rustic wood ceiling panels and a Gothic-styled door that opens onto a balcony. A 244-square-foot bedroom with a wood paneled vaulted ceiling and built-in storage has an intimate garret-like feel to it. The two other bedrooms share a full bathroom with hallway access.
What’s cooking?
The 146-square-foot kitchen features appliances by Bertazzoni, a pretty patterned tiled floor, oversize textured subway tiles on the walls and a ceramic farm sink. A multi-paned door offers egress to the covered porch. Upper storage is a combination of open shelving and closed cabinets. Adjacent to the open space is a 158-square-foot dining area.
What else?
There is original stained glass in the entry foyer and staircase, where the 2022 renovation replaced the staircase, which is a point of focus when entering the home. Other work included sanding and refinishing hardwood floors. The bathrooms have been updated in a traditional style with wainscoting, pedestal sinks, tiled floors and new shower and bath configurations.
Amenities and more
- Built-in basement-level garage with one space
- Wood burning fireplace
- Firepit area in the yard
- Kayak storage spot
Agent’s callout
“The wow factor of this home lies in its seamless blend of history, location and thoughtful updates,” says Moore. “This Victorian gem embodies the charm of Shelter Island Heights with iconic views and proximity to Chase Creek, and offers a rare combination of historic charm and functionality.”
Location, location, location
“This is an unbeatable location close to beaches, golf and other Heights amenities,” Moore says. Just a stone’s throw from the house is the Shelter Island Country Club and Ice Pond Park. Crescent Beach is .6 miles, the North Ferry is .5 miles, as are the Shelter Island Heights Private Beach Club and, in the other direction the yacht club overlooking Dering Harbor on Chequit Avenue.
Details
The home at 42A New York Ave. lists for $1,895,000 and the details can be seen here.
